I know it's been a long time since I posted, but I have made two brews in the interim. Beer 3 was completely unremarkable. I'll post the recipe when I get a chance. It was an English ale and I wasn't a fan of how the hops were used. Also I accidentally got too much yeast into the bottling bucket, and thus the bottles, so it tastes yeasty.
Beer 4 was an Oktoberfest. It was my first lager. I made it last July and will also have more info posted soon, including a recipe. It was easily the best beer I've made to date.